January 30, 2005
The Border Police is planning to demolish an Arab neighborhood in Jerusalem to protect the separation fence built in the area.
Commander Amitai Levy, the Border Police commander of the area
enveloping Jerusalem, has announced that dozens of buildings of the Al-Muntar
neighborhood in Jerusalem's Tzur Baher village must be torn down.
This follows from his decision to create a 500-meter-wide security strip on each
side of the barrier along its entire length, he said.
The residents of Al-Muntar said this week that at least 74 houses come within
500 meters of the barrier. In the rest of the country, the security buffer along
the fence is only 50 to 80 meters wide.
Levy's statement contradicts the instructions of Dan Tirza, a retired colonel in
charge of the security fence administration for the Israel Defense Forces. Tirza
permitted two architect firms hired by the residents to plan the buildings only
dozens of meters away from the fence.
Recently he ratified his decision and said it was reached in coordination with
the IDF command of the area surrounding Jerusalem.
Levy said the illegal buildings will be demolished and "if the whole
neighborhood is illegal, it must be destroyed." He also said Tirza is not
authorized to make any security decisions in the fence region. "He is not a
security authority in this region and cannot legalize illegal buildings,"
he said.
The houses in Al-Muntar were built without a building permit, in the absence of
a master plan in the area. However, their owners have been acting for years
together with the Interior Ministry and Jerusalem municipality to issue legal
permits for the houses that were built.
Attorney Giat Nasser, who represents 27 Al-Muntar residents, said the plans for
the houses were made following the residents' petition to the High Court of
Justice and on the instructions of the Jerusalem municipality.
The architects are working on a master plan for the village, which, once
approved, will render the houses legal. However, red tape is holding up the
plan's approval, and meanwhile the residents keep receiving demolition orders to
their homes.
Although their homes are in the process of being approved, they are forced to
pay heavy fines and make efforts to persuade the courts to withhold the
demolitions.
The residents started building their houses in Al-Muntar in 1992 in the
village's east wing, after three Jewish settlements (the neighborhoods Har Homa,
East Talpiot and Kibbutz Ramat Rahel) were built around Tzur Baher since 1967.
The residents of Tzur Baher, which is mostly inside Jerusalem's municipal area,
said the building in Al-Muntar results from the village's natural growth in the
only unbuilt area left.
The residents were angry this week at Levy's statement. "The commander is
not supposed to promote the demolition of illegal structures. Since when do the
police or Border Police interfere with the affairs of the Jerusalem municipality
or the Interior Ministry?" they asked.
The Jerusalem municipality denied the city is dragging its feet approving the
plans and said it is debating two of the plans submitted by the residents. The
Interior Ministry said, "The Jerusalem district Planning Bureau in the
ministry is handling the residents' calls to replan Tzur Baher's margins."
SOURCE: Haaretz